Saturday, April 9, 2011
What a Woman in Crisis Really Needs
Amidst the debates swirling around about defunding Planned Parenthood, some oft-repeated catch phrases are being tossed around like word grenades. One of these are "women in crisis." I'm sick and tired of hearing about "women in crisis" and how they need access to emergency contraception and abortions. That is a huge, steaming pile of lies, propagated by people who like to murder babies. Women in crisis do not need access to abortions. What they need is love, support, a safe place to live, and people (even strangers!) who will tell them the truth: that they are more than capable of being a mother. That they can do this. That their crisis, no matter how terrible, will be healed in the long, sometimes painful, always joyful process of becoming a mother.
Think this makes me heartless, speaking from my comfortable suburban home, having never known trials in my cushy little life?
Think again.
When I got that positive pregnancy test, the one that changed my life, I was addicted to crystal meth.
And do you know what the people around me did? They didn't take the secular line and say, "this baby's life would be horrible. You're unfit to be a mother. Better for it to not be born at all."
But neither did they take the typical pro-life line in that situation and say, "you are clearly unfit to be a mother, but all you have to do is carry the baby to term and give a stable couple a wonderful gift."
The Ogre said, "you're a mother now, and I'm a father, and together we'll raise our child."
My parents said, "marry that man, and raise that baby. You've made the choices, you have to live with them."
My friends said, "you screwed up, big time. But we love you. We'll throw you a baby shower, buy you maternity clothes, and babysit while you finish your semester."
Don't get me wrong, it wasn't easy, being a newly-pregnant drug addict. But it gave me something to live for. Someone to live for.
Many times, women who are addicted to drugs manage to clean themselves up during the pregnancy only to fall back into old habits after the baby is born. This is why conventional wisdom states that a drug addict can't raise a child, even if she manages to carry the baby safely, healthily to term.
In some women, this is doubtless true. But think of the message we're sending those women.
You can't do this. You are too weak to resist. You're not a mother, you're unfit to be a mother, we know you won't make sacrifices for your child. Better for the child to not live at all than to be abandoned by a drug-addled mother. After all, what kind of life will she have. The daughter of an addict.
We in the pro-life community need to remember that we stand for life...all life. Just as much as that baby needs to be born, the mother needs her child to be born. Becoming a mother is a powerful thing, and I can tell you from experience that a child can bring new-found strength to a woman in a terrible place.
I vividly remember one day, three months after Sienna was born. I managed to get us both dressed and we went for a walk. I walked around our apartment complex, unconsciously making my way to a friend's apartment with drug connections. Before I had really decided to do so, I was knocking at his door. No one was there. I sat on a bench across from his apartment and waited. I waited for an hour, my mind racing all that time. I couldn't get over the one, obvious hurtle. If I were to use drugs again, I couldn't breastfeed the baby. But what excuse could I give for not feeding her? What excuse would I have for using formula? And what if the Ogre figured it out? What if he told my parents? Would the drugs really enter the breastmilk? Would it affect her too much? Couldn't I just smoke a little bit, and then see if she acted funny?
In the midst of this frantic train of thought, I happened to look down at my daughter. She was sleeping, her soft pink mouth open, her little hand curled up against one fat, rosy cheek.
She was absolutely beautiful, and absolutely perfect. I knew the hell of drug use, and in that instant I knew that I could not do that to my daughter. I couldn't let that horror into her tiny, flawless body.
She opened her eyes, yawned, and smiled at me. It was a rare thing for her to smile at me. I was an absent mother, a source of food. We had almost no relationship at all. But at that moment, for the first time, I loved her. I picked her up and held her closely, shaky and nearly weeping from the adrenaline that had been coursing through me. Just as my friend's car pulled up I held Sienna in one arm, turned the stroller around and went home.
From that moment on my half-formed plans to use drugs again began to dissipate. It took years before they were gone completely, and even still, on bad days, the thought sometimes pops into my head, unbidden and quickly chased out.
But my daughter saved my life. She saved me from that terrible crisis. The people around me didn't say, "You can't be a mother. You can't parent. You're addicted to crystal meth, there's no hope for you." They said, "You are a mother now. This is your child. You can, and will, raise her." And I did. I am.
That is what women in crisis really need. They need to be told that this is what they were made for, that motherhood is in their blood, in their very being, and that they can do it. Just as their babies deserve a chance to live, so do they deserve a chance to be a mother.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

This is such a powerful testimony. Thank you so much for sharing it.
ReplyDeleteNicole said exactly what I was going to say, to the letter. I don't know much else to add. I am so glad you shared it, Someone like me could write about an issue like this, but I have zero experience with some of life's truly tough issues, like drugs and unexpected, unwed pregnancies. Your words are poignant because you were there. You know what these women "in crisis'' are going through. Your life is such an amazing proof of how much God's grace can change a person!
ReplyDeleteI just discovered your blog last week and all the posts I've read have been so amazing. Thank you so much for your blog and all that you share with your readers!
ReplyDeleteThat was worthy of a facebook post. Thank you for your courage.
ReplyDeleteThank you Leila for telling me about this blog! That was a beautiful post, perfect and clear truth. Great pro-life slogan...
ReplyDelete"Just as much as that baby needs to be born, the mother needs her child to be born."
I'm so glad I know you!! God is working wonderful things in and through you because you are letting Him.
ReplyDeleteThis is a powerful and courageous post, Calah. Beautiful, too! A beautiful witness to walking the walk that being Pro-Life requires.
ReplyDeleteThis is right on. Thank you. Would you consider doing a post about the logistics of how you overcame your addiction during pregnancy?
ReplyDeleteGod Bless you Calah! You are one powerful woman (doubtless supported by divine grace and the prayers of those who loved you)!
ReplyDeleteI respond to a FB post by a friend who said "why do Republicans care about vaginas?" with "vaginas we don't care about. Women and babies we do."
My good friend (cradle catholic) was coerced into abortion at age 18 by her boyfriend and a "helpful" pediatrician she trusted... I would not wish the he'll she has been through the last 15 years on anyone (she married the BF and they now have 3 boys...but she suffers from depression and they are attending counseling because she blames him for making her kill her first baby)....
Thanks for your honesty! You are an amazing witness for life!!
Beautiful. Thank you SO MUCH for sharing your story and writing this post! I am eager to share it with others!
ReplyDeleteSuch a beautiful post. Thank you for your gut-wrenching honesty.
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful post. Thank you, Calah.
ReplyDeleteYou are an amazing woman, Calah. Thank you for sharing this with such grace and courage. Love you, sweetie!
ReplyDeleteThis is so powerful, I have been thinking about it all day. Have your own experiences shaped your views on parenting- how strict or not strict, how to treat teens etc? I only have littles, but I spend many an anxious night thinking about the tough road ahead for my kids. Just curious of your thoughts. Your words are a powerful witness for good. G
ReplyDeleteWonderful post. I absolutely agree that the expectations we set for people can be the very things that keep them on the path they need. I have often said that sex ed that is not abstinence-based only tells the kids that they are not capable of being abstinent. It gives them a way to not be abstinent. And we ought to work hard to provide a path to abstinence and set the expectation that sex is for marriage instead of give kids the way out and say, "Well, we know you can't be abstinent so here's a condom..."
ReplyDeleteYou are such a strong witness. Thank you for writing this.
Thank you all for your support. I am deeply, deeply appreciative of each comment.
ReplyDeleteKT-I am toying with the idea of doing a series of posts about these aspects of my life. I'd like to come at them from a variety of different angles, but obviously this is a difficult subject to write about (it's taken me half a year to even mention it). I will keep that idea in mind, though.
MJDMom-My experiences have absolutely shaped my views on parenting, in that I am completely terrified. I think I know more than a lot of moms about what is out there, but I have no idea how to combat it. I think we try to strive for very strict on some things (obedience, courtesy) and not so strict on others. As far as teens go, I don't know that I'll be any stricter than my parents were, because they were pretty strict. I do think I'll have a better idea of what to look for and will intervene early if I see any sort of warning signs with my kids. Perhaps the greatest thing I'm coming around to is homeschooling...no matter how small, Catholic or Christian the school is, the culture of death finds it's way inside. I think keeping my kids closer is the best answer, but that may change. My biggest worry, honestly, is that I will overreact and be too clingy in my awareness of the dangers out there and my fear for my children, and in doing so will drive them away.
I do know, from looking at the path my life took, that the unceasing prayer of my parents had a huge impact. I do not believe that I would have come away from what is arguably the most addictive drug in the world if it wasn't for their constant prayer, love and support. I also has a great boyfriend (now husband) and wonderful friends. It seems clear to me that God surrounded me with exactly what and who I needed, and that, I think, will be my most fervent prayer for my children...that God never lets them slip totally from His grasp, no matter how they might struggle.
Thanks for your insight...I attended UD as well and I really feel that having a peer group who knew what was right (though we didn't always do it) is huge! Tipsy people would stop drunk people from going home together and tuck them in rather than wish them well and laugh at them on the way home on the 'walk of shame'. Ultimately, we have to entrust our children to God and obviously we know where He wants them- to be saints in Heaven!
ReplyDelete*salute*
ReplyDeleteAmazing post - I am definitely going to share this with others. Thank you for your honesty!
ReplyDeleteI couldn't let that horror into her tiny, flawless body.
ReplyDelete======
As literal as this is with drugs, in a way, all sin is like this for a parent. Because whenever we mess up, it hurts them to some degree.
Rob
As the daughter of an addict (now in recovery) I would love to hear a firsthand account of an addict, especially a young one. If you're up to it I think it would be great.
ReplyDeleteAmazing story! Simply amazing! Just stumbled upon your blog...SO glad I did! I admire your honesty! You have such a beautiful family :)
ReplyDeleteActually, what a woman "in crisis" needs is support, and the chance to decide for herself what course of action is best for her. She needs nonjudgemental information, and a safe place to go regardless of what decision she makes. Being forced to have a child may have been a great thing for you, but it may not be so for other women. Some women's greatest goal in life is not to be "barefoot and pregnant," at least not until they're ready and willing to do so. Please, don't be so close-minded as to think that the path you took is the right path for everyone. Life is about all of us finding the path that's best for us.
ReplyDeleteIn response to "Choice"...
ReplyDeleteFrederica Mathewes-Green made this accurate quote: "A woman doesn't want an abortion like she wants an ice cream cone or a Porsche, but rather like an animal caught in a trap who gnaws off its own leg."
Women don't choose abortion because it's just another viable choice when you become pregnant..."hmmm, should i abort, put up for adoption or keep the baby?"
Women choose abortion because they feel/think they have no other choice, and that's not "choice," that's hopelessness. I, for one, don't want to be a part of that kind of hopelessness. Women deserve better.
We just plain old disagree, and that's fine of course. I DO happen to think it's a viable choice. If I became pregnant, those are exactly the three courses of action I would ponder because those are the three choices I have. For some women, the decision might come from a sense of hopelessness, but for me and for many others it would be a conscientious decision-making process. Do I want to have a child right now? No. Do I want to have children in the future? Probably. I am a woman living in a time where, fortunately, I have the means and the right to make the decision to become a mother when I am ready and able to. Ideally, those decisions would be well thought-through ahead of time, and a woman who doesn't currently want a child would be using effective contraceptive methods or would choose not to be sexually active. In the real world, though, women get pregnant unintentionally (I believe the current figure is 30-50% of pregnancies are unplanned)and need to have the ability to make the choice they want to make. Not because they've lost all hope, but because they screwed up/something didn't go according to plan/something beyond their control happened and they don't want to continue down the path of motherhood at that particular time.
ReplyDeleteI just don't believe that the ability to make a decision is synonymous with hopelessness. Don't believe in abortion? Then don't have one. Simple as that. But don't be so self-righteous and naive to think that everyone else should follow your beliefs.
Choice- do you think suicide is okay? I'm just curious about your take on that particular issue. By the typical pro-abortion reasoning, a woman is in charge of her body. Does that line of reasoning extend to suicide? It is my body, therefore I should be able to kill it. If suicide is not for you, don't do it. "But don't be so self-righteous and naive to think that everyone else should follow your beliefs. " How far does the choice extend?
ReplyDeleteSuicide is painful and awful but if someone desires not to live anymore, they have within their means and their right to take their own life. We are the masters of our own destiny. Why should anyone be told they don't have the right to make a decision for themselves? It's a selfish and often foolish decision, but a decision a person can make nonetheless.
ReplyDeleteAlso, do not refer to my viewpoint as pro-abortion. I think abortion is an awful, terrible, painful thing and I wish it didn't exist. I wish the world was perfect and no one ever found themselves in a situation where they were unwillingly pregnant. But people find themselves in this position every day, and deserve the right to make their own decision. I am pro-choice, not pro-abortion.
PS: Calah,
ReplyDeleteThis is my first time visiting your blog. I love it! You write so beautifully and honestly. I feel proud to know you. What a wonderful testimony; it reveals the depth of your experience and the wisdom that God has blessed you with. I'm so happy for you and your family. You are truly a special person.
-Tiffany (Brown) Johnson
I believe in God, not a God that is oppressive, but a God that loves me. A God that, much like a parent, has rules to help us stay safe and happy. A parent does not have rules because she doesn't want to allow her child self-expression. A parent has rules because she wants to protect her child from pain. God loves us in the same way but even more deeply and more completely. Please don't be so narrow-minded as to discount this viewpoint. I would never say to someone I cared about, "sure, break the rules and open the door to a world of heartache. If that's what you believe then it must be okay". That's not love; it's cowardice. There is a right and a wrong. The world is not relative. If it were, then life would have no meaning. It's funny- you are pro-choice, but you don't include the choice to believe that abortion is wrong. I guess the choices are limited to what you think they should be...
ReplyDeleteAlso- I don't want to take over my friend's blog with this most lengthy discussion topic. If you are actually interested in discussing it, maybe we could do it elsewhere.
Tiffany! I've been wondering how you are! (I'll perhaps send you a catch-up message via facebook, though?) Thanks for coming by!
ReplyDeleteBy all means, feel free to hijack my comment box. I will enjoy reading the discussion.
Choice, I'm actually writing a post right now directly addressing your comments. Unfortunately I truly do not have the time to hash this issue out via the comment box, but I do have a few things I'd like to say. Please feel free to respond either at that post or on this one, and if I have time I will answer you. But do understand that I'm not ignoring you or unwilling to discuss things, I'm just a busy housewife and only allot a certain amount of time per day to blogging and blog-related things.
It makes me smile to hear what light Sienna brought to a dark place in your life.
ReplyDeleteI was 22, struggling with alcohol abuse, smoking a pack (or so) of cigarettes a day, hardly eating or sleeping, trying to get out of an abusive family situation and dealing with a burgeoning anxiety disorder when I got my first positive pregnancy test.
I am so thankful for that baby. God only knows how low I could have gotten if it weren't for having someone precious and innocent to shape up for. I too am very glad that abortion was (at least mentally) not an option for me. It would have made it too easy to give up on myself and my baby.
Now I'm still rather odd, very anxious and struggle to eat enough but I don't abuse alcohol or smoke anymore. My kids are healthy and happy and have a very empathetic mom. So, I guess I wasn't as bad of a maternal prospect as I seemed on paper.
Tiffany, you brought to light a lot of points, and I'll try to address each of them.
ReplyDeleteYour beliefs on this topic stem from your belief in your God. Not everyone believes in this God, or any God, and therefore derive their morals and beliefs from other sources. Mine, for example, stem from empathy, logical thought, and the values my sense of humanity instills in me.
Secondly, I don't think right and wrong are absolute. Right and wrong lie in the interpretations of human beings, along with what our society and/or religion may tell us. That being said, this sense of black and white does not make the world or life any less meaningful. If your religion any less meaningful to you because there is no proof of it? No. The concreteness of something is not directly related to its meaning.
Also, at no point did I say that believing abortion to be wrong is not a choice. In fact, I addressed it directly - twice. As living beings with the ability to think for ourselves, we are entitled to believe what we believe. That includes both your belief that abortion should not be a choice, and my belief that it should be.
If you'd like to end this conversation here, I'm happy to do so. I'm sure we could talk for hours and weeks and years, and neither of us would probably change our beliefs. But I think it's important for us to discuss our deeply-held beliefs, and to re-examine them in the light of other people's beliefs. I hope that some of what I've said has given you food for thought, as your comments have done for me. Beliefs are meaningless if we do not question them and truly challenge why we believe them, to make them stronger.
I respect each and every one of you who have made the decision to be dedicated mothers. What I do not respect, however, is your desire to force your lifestyle and your beliefs on others. That would be akin to me rallying against your right to express your religion because I do not share your beliefs. That would be selfish, senseless, close-minded and stupid.
There are 7 billion human beings in the world, and we would all benefit greatly from respectful discussion and open-mindedness.
Have a great day everyone!
This is my third attempt at a comment (blogger hates me), so I'm going to keep it short.
ReplyDeleteAs the child of a drug addict (my dad), it's so good to read stories of people who were able to overcome their addiction for their children. Thank you so much for sharing.
Choice, I love choice for women, until it comes to infringing on the very right to life of another person. That is a right no one has. We never have permission to take an innocent life. Not ever. Don't you think "not killing the innocent" is a good principle for a society to live by?
ReplyDeleteAnd, are you concerned that up to 2/3 of all abortions are coerced in some way, so not a free "choice"? I hope you are fighting against coercive abortions, which are the norm. Women deserve better.
Coercive abortions are the norm? I have never heard that before. Show me your evidence and I'll consider that a valid point.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I love that the "better" you think women deserve is being forced into decisions they don't want to make.
And on a side note, you say "We never have permission to take an innocent life. Not ever."
ReplyDeleteOut of curiosity, what did you have for dinner today?
Choice, sorry, I thought you could infer that I meant "human" life. I believe human life is sacred. Not animal life.
ReplyDeleteGo here to find out more about coerced abortions. Happens every single day:
http://www.theunchoice.com/coerced.htm
Lots of stats and facts to look at. Very sad indeed.
PS: I believe it's okay to kill innocent mosquitos, too.
ReplyDeleteHuman beings? Not so much.
How lovely and convenient and comforting that you believe for some reason that you are sacred, but all other non-human animals aren't. Why are those creations of God not sacred, and you are?
ReplyDeleteI spent some time on that website. I will never argue that coerced abortion is an atrocity. Being pro-choice, I believe in the choice of a woman to make her decision. I do not believe that others should make that decision for her. Therefore, in the same vein that I do not believe in stripping a women of her option to terminate her pregnancy, I do not believe in someone other than herself forcing to end her pregnancy. The principles are one and the same.
But this is a non sequitur. Illegalizing abortion and/or not presenting it as an option does not address the issue of this type of abuse. Should abortion be illegal or not available, these pressurizing forces who are coercing women into giving up their babies wouldn't just give up and say "Oh well, guess we're having a baby and I should become a loving parent." They would pursue illegal and dangerous methods of pregnancy termination, and even more women would suffer and die.
A powerful story- you are an inspiration.
ReplyDeleteChoice, do you think a mosquito is the same as a boy? They have the same value and moral standing? If so, we just have a big difference of opinion. I do believe that human life is sacred and inviolable, and that animal life is not. That does not mean that we treat animals inhumanely, of course, but they are not equal to humans.
ReplyDeleteIf I had a choice to avoid hitting either a dog or a child with my car, I would swerve to avoid the child and hit the dog. I would feel bad about the dog, but it would never occur to me to pick the dog's life over the child's. I'm assuming you would pick the child, too?
As far as "more women" suffering and dying if abortion were illegal again, check this site for stats on that whole argument:
http://www.abortionfacts.com/online_books/love_them_both/why_cant_we_love_them_both_27.asp
Blessings!
I will end my commenting on this issue on this thread as well. I leave you with my final thoughts.
ReplyDeleteMy primary goal here is not to insult all of you; it is to provide a dissenting viewpoint that is too frequently lacking in these types of blogs. If our deepest-held convictions go unquestioned and unchallenged, then we may as well forfeit our reasoning minds and walk this earth on autopilot.
Leila: Either life is sacred or it is not. Your distinction between human creations of God and non-human creations of God is arbitrary. Why would God populate the earth with creatures, and decide that one species is sacred and others can be tortured and killed? (If you don't believe that the animals you eat for food are tortured, educate yourself and your loved ones on factory farming). I’m sure several of you will want to cite the Bible to disprove that argument, but save your breath. The Bible is not a source of evidence. It is a work of fiction written to influence the lives of religious constituents, in the pursuit of power and money. I could no more sanely cite a Mother Goose tale as evidence for my arguments. In my opinion, the entire religion of Catholicism has served much more as a tool of imperialism than a guideline for moral living. Have you ever wondered why the use of contraception is so strongly discouraged by the Catholic faith? It is not to respect the “sanctity of life,” or to keep intact the “holy act” of intercourse. Those are the feel-good reasons they have instilled in you to cover up the true and original intent of these rules. This stipulation of your faith was designated to increase the Catholic population. Think about it. A group of people set out to utilize a religion to amalgamate and brainwash their constituents. But how to increase the likelihood that your religion and your brainwashing will be as effective and as widespread as possible? Simple. Teach them that they need to reproduce as many times as possible, and that any prevention of reproduction is a sin. Ta-da! Your numbers grow stronger and you gain more power. If the Catholic church truly believed all human life to be sacred, would the Pope have sanctioned the Crusades? Would it continue to wage war against homosexuality when those efforts could be spent saving lives in third world countries? There are so many holes in the Catholic ‘sanctity of life’ argument. “Life is sacred…unless it’s a different species…or a different religion….or people who think differently than we do. Then it’s okay to torture and kill.”
The bottom line is that this earth is as we see it. There is a lot of love, there is hatred, there is pain, and there is beauty. But we shouldn’t need some imaginary man in the sky or some sexually-repressed, oddly-outfitted man in Rome to tell us to live our lives as good people. Our relationships with others, our empathy, and our nature as human beings should encourage us to do so. Not because we fear eternal punishment or strive for eternal reward, but because being a decent person is the right way to live. We are animals, just like any other, who reproduce because it is written in our genetic code (which there is actually proof of). Life can be a beautiful thing, babies can grow up to be presidents or researchers or peacemakers. But life can also be painful and horrible. Babies can grow up to be criminals and rapists and serial killers. What about the millions of children starving and dying of preventative diseases all over the world? Why are you not campaigning to save their lives if life is, in fact, sacred? Why is your primary concern to get as many children into the world as possible, when welfare programs are already spread too thin, there are already so many children living in squalor and poverty, and there are parents who abuse their kids? Why the focus on quantity, not quality? How about instead of bringing more souls into the world, you adopt and care for those that are already in existence who desperately need love and assistance? I would assert that your allowing these souls to suffer in order to produce children genetically related to you is just as disrespectful to the sanctity of life as a woman who chooses not to carry a pregnancy to term. If some superior being had wanted us to reproduce endlessly, he or she would have made the resources of this earth limitless to satisfactorily provide for all of those lives. But they are not, and we cannot all pop out one child after another without society and the earth at some point caving under the weight of this ceaseless breeding. This does not make me loveless; this makes my definition of love one based on reality rather than religion.
ReplyDeleteSo go on living in your bubble and feeling all warm and fuzzy about the way you conduct your lives. Go on crusading against the thousands of unborn children who aren’t brought into this world every day, while you pay thousands of dollars every year to companies who torture and kill other of God’s “sacred” creatures for the sake of your taste buds. Keep telling yourselves that sex before marriage is okay as long as you hurry up and get married before the baby comes, that divorce is okay as long as you pay the church an adequate sum of money to pretend the marriage never existed, that parts of the Bible are necessary for everyone to follow but others can be swept under the rug if they inconvenience you, that torturing and killing is okay as long as it’s a member of a species or a thought doctrine other than your own.
ReplyDeleteIn short, keep living in your Catholic bubble if it’s too painful for you to think outside the brainwash that comes prefabricated in the neat and tidy package of religion. But keep your brainwash to yourselves and let the rest of us live as we see fit as well. I will never protest your right to live your life as you please. Stop protesting my right to do the same (and yes, 'my life' includes my decision whether or not to bear children).
Wow, Choice. This is the response I get for extending you the hand of mutual amiability and respect in spite of our differing opinions? So much for tolerance.
ReplyDeleteI've actually deliberated whether or not to delete your comments, but I've decided to let them stand so that everyone reading can see which side is the one "spewing vitriol." But please do not comment again unless you plan to apologize to me and my readers for your ignorant and inflammatory insults. If you leave another comment like those above, I will delete it and ban you from my blog.
Look, Choice, we're not trying to oppress you. We're trying to keep babies from being murdered. It truly makes me want to weep that our protection of innocent children inspires such wrath in you. If I were you, I would seriously examine your conscience and ask yourself whether or not this response does, in fact, make you "loveless".
I didn't realize I was being wrathful for providing the reasons for my opinions and beliefs. I'm sorry you feel that way, and that you think my side of this debate has in any way been more insulting or intolerant than yours has. I guess if I don't agree with you I'm not allowed to be straightforward and honest without being deemed ignorant and inflammatory.
ReplyDeleteI hope you'll provide your readers with the ability to read and interpret my opinions for themselves, and won't delete them simply to do away with a little conflict.
Signing off, still appreciative of the space for debate and discussion, and sorry that you think I'm out of line. I thought the purpose of blogs was to toss around ideas and get each other thinking.
Cheers.
Choice, wow. You don't think what you said was inflammatory or insulting? It actually is classic anti-Catholic bigotry. Were you a Woman's Studies or Diversity Studies major? The intolerance of the "tolerant" is a stunning irony.
ReplyDeleteCalah, there is so much her to refute. Do I have your permission to use Choice's comments on my own blog?
Just let me know...
Leila, have at it! I really look forward to reading it!
ReplyDeleteyou are incredible. your story is incredible and your daughter is a miracle...she is proof, you are proof that there should not be a "choice" because all life is precious. thank you for being so brave and sharing your story
ReplyDeleteThanks, Calah!
ReplyDeleteI unfortunately don't have time to sift through all of the comments, but I want to echo what some other folks are saying: Thank you for this beautifully honest post. Thank you for your courage. Thank you for trust, your love, and sharing the beauty that is you.
ReplyDeleteCalah, thank you for sharing a very inspiring story.
ReplyDeleteAs for "choice", well, I commend the rest of you for being far more patient and even-tempered than I would have been in my responses. I have met far too many morally bankrupt and confused people like "choice" in my life - women who weep for baby seals and chickens but coldly shrug off the murder of their own species. These same people flatter themselves that they are "compassionate."
Do I want to have a child right now? No. Do I want to have children in the future? Probably. I am a woman living in a time where, fortunately, I have the means and the right to make the decision to become a mother when I am ready and able to.
ReplyDeleteI guess this sums up the prevalent attitude of our time, doesn't it.
Oh, and Calah, grat post!
Calah,
ReplyDeleteThank you! We need more women to share their stories like this in order to give more women courage to share their lives and open up their hearts. I was 19 when I got pregnant. I did not love the father but I tried to make it work---he was older and I was very very immature.
I was one of the lucky ones, with a support system, like you. I moved back in with my parents and got a job. I saved for a car. Next, I moved out. I went back to school. I met a wonderful man who loved me from the beginning even when I still couldn't extend myself too much to anyone (other than my baby girl).
I look back on my lifestyle when I found myself pregnant and I thank God for saving me from the pit of shallow, empty lifelessness. We are so lucky God loves us enough to send us an innocent life in order to open our eyes.
I was a college student when I discovered I was pregnant. At the time, I looked down on young mothers and didn't want to be married. My boyfriend never hesitated for a moment. He wanted to marry me and raise our child. I decided I couldn't do it-that I would give the baby up for adoption. I called Catholic Services. A woman there urged me to tell my parents that I was pregnant. My mother was not happy with me, but she would not hear of me giving the baby up. I'll never forget her words: "You are going to get married, raise your child and make your marriage work."
ReplyDeleteThat is exactly what I did. I have been married for 31 1/2 years to my wonderful, wonderful husband. My daughter is 31 years old, married with 3 three children of her own. My husband and I have 3 other children.
It was not easy. We struggled to finish school and have had many struggles over the years. But I have always thought that God sent that baby to stop me in my tracks. I was on a destructive path. What a beautiful gift. I am a blessed woman, very happily married to a man I love and who loves me. I had the joy and privilege of raising my daughter and my other children, and now I have the joy of seeing my daughter excelling as a wife and mother.
When I found out that I was pregnant, it did feel like a crisis. But once the baby was born I loved her with all my heart. The baby was not a crisis. She was, and is, a blessing.
wow. thanks for sharing this
ReplyDeleteBeautiful post. Thank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteBreathtaking. Beautiful. What a wonderously brave woman you are.
ReplyDeleteI think this was a great story and was inspiring and everything, but I'm trying to think about this practically. It's well known that many drugs, including alcohol, nicotine, meth, benzodiazepines, and many others are harmful to the baby and can cause birth defects and low birth weight, as well as future problems in adulthood. What if someone got pregnant, but didn't know until 6 weeks later, during which they had gotten very drunk several times at least? They know there's a distinct chance of severe defects and a high likelihood of premature birth and low birthweight, so what should they do? Have a baby that may be partially retarded and have to care for a baby that may not even experience life nearly normally? And have the undue amount of stress, mentally and monetarily, in caring for a handicapped child that may not even be able to be grateful or even benefit from it? This is a serious question and I appreciate serious, non-condescending answers. Thanks for your article and input.
ReplyDeleteWOW, Anonymous! Thanks for sharing! My life-saving blessing is 9 :)
ReplyDeleteJake, ALL life has inherent dignity and value. A child with down-syndrome or fetal-alcohol syndrome is of no less value than you or I. Be careful when you start placing different values on human life. We have seen what can happen with such instances like Nazi Germany and the Slave Trade.
ReplyDeleteJake, thanks for the comment. I think this is certainly a valid question. I will always take the side of life, no matter what the results are. I do think that a woman with a drug addiction should immediately cease using (as I did, and believe me it was hell and I was literally not left alone for three weeks, as I couldn't be trusted to be on my own). The pregnancy should then continue.
ReplyDeleteWhat if the woman doesn't have the support I did? What if she doesn't stop her drug or alcohol abuse?
Well, then I believe the baby should still be born. I've seen meth babies, and I know how awful it is. I know how much pain they are in and how truly terrible their tiny lives are, and yet I still believe they deserve life.
As far as the mother goes, if she's unwilling to discontinue her use, she should not be allowed to parent. There are many charities out there which specialize in children who are born with disabilities, and many adoptive parents who specifically seek out special-needs children, so the child would not necessarily be shuttled into the often loveless, dangerous foster care system.
And even if the child was shuttled into the foster care system...isn't that better than being dead? A life of difficulty and disability is better than no life at all.
You also never know what effect actually seeing her child might have on the mother. It could be powerful enough to turn her around.
To everyone else, thank you all so much for your comments and support. I can't tell you how much I appreciate each one.
Thank you for this post. Thank you for choosing life. God bless you for witness!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Calah, for your thoughtful post, and for your thoughtful response to Choice. I was Choice once (minus the atheist vitriol and the PETA rhetoric). I defended PP clinics and was furious at the religious folks praying in my direction. I saw the Catholic Church in particular for its human failings and focused on the flaws in its history. I was--even am still--a feminist, though I'd define that differently now. But I am now a Catholic, and the recognition I had that the failings of the Catholic Church are the failings of humanity was a real epiphany. Catholicism is a scapegoat for a lot of things, but whatever the atrocities perpetuated in the name of the Church, the Church is us: humans, God's people, the body of Christ. Accepting Catholicism is an act of humility: it means saying "yes, humans screw up, and the Catholic Church, based in God's love and taking up the mantle of Christ, is nonetheless human." And God knew this. Christ had to smack down Peter, the rock on which he built his Church, more than once for getting things wrong and even--let us not forget--betraying him! But this is us! For the non-religious readers, think of this as accepting Universal Love whose boundaries are infinite even though we are flawed and unable fully to grasp it. To make the Catholic Church the scapegoat for humanity's failings is proud, blind, and foolish.
ReplyDeleteBut I can see that in some ways, Choice is trying to articulate, sans religion, a similar idea: the need to be decent to others. She just can't maintain that decency long enough to accept a faith that is based in others and encourages humility as a path to that decency. Indeed, the atheist approach is pretty un-humble: it assumes that everything can be understood. Most of the best scientists don't actually think that, though neither scientists nor Catholics think we should therefore stop trying to understand. We just know that the human mind has limits, and we respect the mystery of the universe. Many philosophic, theological, and critical traditions get to this same place by different paths.
continued from above...
ReplyDeleteAnd to address Choice's comments about supporting life after birth: I've said the same thing. What most non-Catholics don't understand is that the Church does actually commit itself, doctrinally and practically, to helping the poor, to supporting women with difficult pregnancies, and in other ways putting their money where their mouths are! Indeed, I was told in no uncertain terms in RCIA that if I joined up, I was committing myself to the poor, that the face of Christ was there.
I do believe that most pro-choice people hold their position through a sense of sympathy, empathy, even love. I was trying to "help" my sisters in pain. The blind spot I shared with her is the blind spot about why, as she said, abortion is a "awful, painful, terrible thing" and she "wishes it didn't exist." If it is awful and painful, why? Why should it be infrequent? Why avoid it? Why is it that so many people who call themselves pro-choice admit that abortion should be avoided? It should be avoided because they have a sneaking suspicion that it might be, well, killing a person. And they are willing to defend the right of everyone to "choice" and "freedom" even when that right extends to, say, ending the life of a 22-week-old fetus who may well be viable outside the womb (as my friend's 3 year old testifies) and who can certainly cry, suck her thumb, and feel pain like an extra-uterine infant, just to allow for the possibility that a woman in "crisis" might have a tough time raising a child. If that 22-week-old fetus travelled 10 inches, it would be a person and we would decry the murderer. Otherwise, yeah, it's the woman's choice to have it stabbed in the head, because to admit otherwise might mean that someone somewhere might have to raise a child she didn't want. It is, in my experience, an uncomfortable truth. Pro-choice people rarely look it in the face. We focus instead on the raped 12-year-old who might give birth to her father's child, or the ancephalic baby. Know what? Hard cases. But should every woman have a right to kill a baby because of those cases? Everyone?
Here's a case. There's a black spot on that ultrasound at 22 weeks that COULD be a horrible birth defect that means the child might live a month or two. 37 weeks: ultrasound shows a child who might be borderline microcephalic. The child is born, head is 89th percentile, and guess what? No health problems, kid smart as a whip. Making it up? Nope. My kid.
I would tell any pro-choice readers that it is really important to think through the full implications of your position. Assume the best of the people who are pro-life. And don't assume that all Catholics are brainwashed simpletons. Indeed, you might consider that there are institutions that benefits from contraception and abortion, and that maybe you are an unwitting participant in those institutions. I can tell you that very few Catholics are unwitting participants in their institution. How could they be? They just may not always take the time to explain their core values and logic to people who are treating them inhumanely.
Chesterton once wrote of the madman, "perhaps the nearest we can get to expressing it is to say this: that his mind moves in a perfect but narrow circle. A small circle is quite as infinite as a large circle; but, though it is quite as infinite, it is not so large. In the same way the insane explanation is quite as complete as the sane one, but it is not so large." Catholicism is, once you're inside, much larger than it seems; indeed, infinitely large. And once you're inside, some other things that seem perfectly logical are, to put it kindly, "perfect but narrow circles."
Thank you for posting this Calah. In my last pregnancy, I was told (on the feast day of Our Lady of Guadalupe, no less) that my son via ultrasound may have a congenital heart defect that may result in immediate emergency surgery after birth as well as cysts on his brain that could be related to Trisomy 13, a death sentence. In that moment, I answered my MFM doctor with this sentence, I will carry him to term, he is still my son. A defect of any kind would not make him any less. The length of his life after birth do not make him less. He is a thriving almost two-year-old now with none of those issues. But I have been in the seat of a woman in a "crisis pregnancy" which is not only the definition of an unwanted, or unexpected pregnancy but one that results in a special needs child or child with physical or mental impairments. And for the record, I do have a special needs child. My daughter, my oldest, has autism. There are no pre-natal screens for autism (although I do not consent to any pre-natal screening regardless) and the world IS a better place with this beautiful little girl who some would see as a burden and would have chosen to murder if they knew.
ReplyDeleteWow, Calah. Just got here from Kate Wicker's blog and I am filled with emotion. After having just walked out of a meeting with pro-lifers about how we can best support women in difficult places to help them treasure life, the timing is God given.
ReplyDeleteI have walked the road of a life saving (mine) pregnancy-and went on to have eight more. I have been married to their dad for nearly 27 years. When I came to my own father to tell him the news of that first baby, his exact words: "every child is a miracle, and that's my grandbaby. Your timing is bad, but you have the opportunity now to make everything that happens from now on good- for you, your baby, and his father." I am weeping right now at the memory, and it was 27 years ago. And things are wonderful.
Thank you, sweet mamma.
May God richly bless you for speaking words of truth, healing, and courage in a world which considers abortion to be an easy "out". Thank you - THANK YOU - for choosing life.
ReplyDeleteCallah, thank you for this post. In response to Choice: Having attempted suicide, I would say you have never known true despair. At the moment before I threw the plugged in radio into my bathtub while I was in it, I said a prayer. "God, if it is not time for me to go, if you have other plans for me, let me live." And so I did. I was married the next year, and my son was born a few years later. The despair of the drug addicted mother and the suicidal woman are not that different. But despair is the sin of Judas. Is that what you believe in?
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your courageous story.
ReplyDeleteAs for the comments made by CHOICE: you claim to know all about the Catholic Church's intentions as to why they are against contraception!
So the secret is our everyone the Catholic Church is against birth control because it wants to fill it's pews!
How about you try reading the document written by Pope Paul Vl in 1968 titled Humane Vitae before you go touting the Catholic Church's intentions!
You'll see the Catholic Church has far more concern for the lives of people regardless of their faith and values women much greater than most so called Feminists do.
Funny how Pope Paul Vl was years ahead of the scientific community on the fact that birth control pill are a form of aborficiants!
I don't blame you Choice, your logic comes from not having belief in something that is greater than yourself! That's why all of your values, ethics, and beliefs are based within those limits and to you there is no absolute right or wrong answers. Everything is subjected to the limits of your own mindset, and with that level of self-centerness, what is right or wrong will always be relative to your circumstance and on your own self justification. Where as with God truth is not relative, it does not change, it has no adgenda.
God created all the animals and gave man dominion over them, so please get off that PETA crap! I adore my cats as much as anyone, my heart breaks when I see animals abused or used for experiments, however, they are not on the same level as human life although they sometimes treat each other a lot better than humans, they at least give birth to their offspring!
I will end with a favorite quote of mine by Ronald Reagan "I have noticed that everyone who is for abortion, has already been born"
LisaC
Your testimony is beautiful and brings so much hope! Thank you for sharing it! God bless - Laura A.
ReplyDeleteWhat an amazing story, Calah. Thank you for bravely sharing it!
ReplyDelete-The Mutschlers
Thank you for sharing your story. And for taking the heat that your story has brought. You are a brave woman.
ReplyDeleteI can't say that I know where you are coming from because I've never walked that road. However, one of my hearts desires is to be one of those people that not only says, "You can do this!" But adds, "And I'm here to help" True Christian love, reaches out, not to save someone (only Christ does that) but to hold the hand of someone in need and be there with support. "Carry one another's burdens" Love in action.
ReplyDeleteThank You for sharing your life with others.
Simply speaking, may God continue to bless you. I can't wait to see His plans for you! Thank you for sharing your story, ad I pray that other women are led to see their true worth.
ReplyDeleteWell I'm really late to this party...just came over from CMR...sooooo glad I did. This is an awesome story. Keep up the great posts! Have a blessed Holy Week!
ReplyDeleteWow! How I wish I had read your story before I met the person in this story. Maybe I would have said and done things differently. Thank you so much for being a mother to your daughter and for sharing your story with the rest of us.
ReplyDeletehttp://annebender.blogspot.com/2010/02/beautiful-blessed-life.html
Thanks for all the comments, you guys. The stories in this combox are amazing! I wish I could get to them all individually, but since I can't, I just want to thank you all for contributing, for sharing your stories, and most of all for defending life. I'm so honored to count myself among your numbers.
ReplyDeleteThank You for sharing, I volunteer in the foster care system, it's so important to help the mom as well as the child.
ReplyDeleteChoice - I'm an agnostic, but a humanist. You don't need a religion to form a pro-life opinion. Abortion is an extreme violation of human rights because the unborn child is both human and alive and that fact cannot be argued. There is no basis for any human right if the right to life is arbitrarily denied to human beings at any stage of their development. Until abortion is made illegal, it becomes very important for women to collectively choose to be the guardians of this most basic right and it is a moral obligation to encourage the choice that protects life.
ReplyDeleteLater still...thanks Zelda for weighing in from another angle of "life-support". Protecting the unborn...it makes infinite sense from a natural law stance, not just a religious one!
ReplyDeleteAs for Choice, I wanted to add that at least those of us who protect human life over animal life because we believe there is a higher value to human life are consistent. If one believes life of all species is of equal value, and then only argues to protect the non-human life, where is the sense in that?
I will be posting this article on MY blog. Wonderful work Calah. An inspiring story.
This is wonderful. Do you mind if I repost on my blog? I've actually just started abortion research to try and understand the issue. I am ardently pro-life, but am trying to start my research with an open mind to understand the issues that surround it. But what you've just said is what I feel and know in my core. Very nice.
ReplyDeleteCalah,
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for sharing your powerful story. And you are so right - women in crisis need SUPPORT!
While in University, my best friend did a work study at our student health services centre. One of her tasks was doing some filing in medical records. And it sickened her that much of the filing - transfered from the local hospital - was for abortions for the student population. I know 2 people who had unplanned pregnancies, then babies, during University; both had great family support and were able to finish their degrees. But what is there for those young women who feel alone and are petrified that they cannot finish their education? These sorts of services were not well publicized, if they were around. And I am certain that they'd have made a difference. We are great at helping high school students finish their degrees if they have children, but what about those in early adulthood?
I believe that the pro-life movement would gain much more traction if we put more emphasis on developing support systems for those in crisis pregnancies in their later teens/early 20s. I am not 100% how, but that is where I think the worst of the problem lies.
Kill yourself.
ReplyDeleteDear Anonymous,
ReplyDeleteI am praying for you! And Calah, know that when you elicit such a powerful and violent reaction you have really caused someone's conscience to wake up and flip out. Good work!
Calah,
ReplyDeleteWhen the devil himself starts posting comments on your blog, I think you knkow you're doing something right. :-)
Calah, I'd go ahead and delete that comment, especially because it was "Anonymous." If the cowardly a**hole doesn't even have the balls to own his words, he doesn't need a platform to spew them.
ReplyDeleteIn response to formerly-pro-choice Anonymous: thank you. I am pro-choice and your post was the first time I have ever somewhat understood the pro-life position. I really just couldn't get why you all care so much what other women are doing when, the vast majority of the time, pro-life largely comes off as angry, self-righteous, insulting, cold and impersonal towards the mother. At least from my perspective as a woman who faced an unplanned pregnancy as a teen. I have a really hard time seeing the love of God when plastic babies and harsh judgments are thrown at terrified young women outside clinics. I get visions of the Magdalene Laundries the way 'support' and adoption are often presented to unwed and teen moms. Remembering that forced closed adoption used to be the only 'option' sheds light on why women are not running to the church with their unplanned pregnancies. I seriously think 'over-the-cuckoo's nest' when I see political ads on TV showing bloody fetuses. Really? That's working to change hearts? If you want to be effective and convincing, the first thing to do is quit telling and start listening. Acknowledge that 40 weeks of pregnancy is not 'nothing', even for a mom who desperately wants a child, much less an unwanted (not just unplanned) pregnancy, which feels more like having a life-ending disease. Acknowledge life - the mother's life - matters too and that she isn't responsible for the plight of infertile couples. Tell the truth about abortion and adoption: when you present myths like childbirth has no health risks, all adoptive parents honor contact agreements and 90 % of abortions lead to PTSD and sterility, women can sense your personal agenda and disingenuousness. If she changes her mind from abortion to adoption, it will be because someone cared about HER, with total compassion, love and understanding. Isn't that the right of every pregnant woman?
ReplyDelete- Sara